Homeowner says neighbor wants another $3,000 per house to plow their shared driveway after failing to secure the same snow clearing service and using part of the $2,000 already paid for next year’s lawn care

Advertisement

Neighbor wants extra money for private driveway snow removal after failing to secure the original contract.

A snowplow clearing the snow from roads.
A yellow plow pushes through packed snow on the side of a road.
Snowplow clearing snow from a rural road in front of a house.
A large snowplow pushes through a deep accumulation of snow
Gravel driveway flanked by fences and woods.
ixnayhombre Having dealt with people in my personal life who were very good at obfuscating financial issues/hidden debt/theft, this behavior could possibly indicate they are misusing the funds. I would be asking for a paper trail on payments to contractors, especially the lawn prepayment (who does that?).
NoodlesAlDente Can you draw us a map? And the $500/mo is collective for the whole block and not 500 per house correct?
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) Per house
Conversation No9040 I don't get it. Draw a map. How big is your driveway? How much snow do you get?
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) It snows 5-6 times per year where its sticks with several inches
DrewguyDC Do you disagree with the principle of sharing expenses with everyone, or just that the guy organizing things didn't in your view work hard enough to obtain a better deal? Either way I'd pay but use this as an opportunity to formalize an agreement and a process for deciding on how to contract in the future.
via DrewguyDC
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) I disagree that they didn't communicate months ago that there was no contract and then out of the blue are asking for twice as much money when I thought the expense was covered. Now I don't have time to find my own provider or buy a snow blower
godweasle You don't have time to buy a snowblower?
via godweasle
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) Snowblowers are expensive and it takes time to save, had I known months ago I could have saved for the purchase instead of other things
njdevils101 It's November, you have time to post on Reddit but not enough time to find someone to remove snow or buy a snowblower? You need to get your priorities straight.
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) Snowblowers are expensive and up until yesterday I was under the impression I had paid for snow clearance already. Now that it is November, I do not have a long runway to save money for an unexpected large purchase around the holidays. I have my priorities straight, you don't need to worry about the 5 minutes of time it took me to run something by Reddit
DrewguyDC I understand the frustration. Just seems like your solution is more spiteful than practical. Why not tell the guy "look, you dropped this on us last minute while putting the money towards landscaping. I'll pay you, but over the next few months, $100/month" or something.
via DrewguyDC
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) It sounds like the money needs to be paid up front. I would rather shovel it myself than pay an excessive amount because a few errors were made. My rub is not with collaborating for a solution, it's with only being given the options to pay up or else
Lucky7366 In general it may be time to say I will allow the use of my property for access so long as it is maintained by the other homes. Should this maintenance drop off, the access will be closed. They can sort another way not using your property. This whole arrangement seems like someone's grift.
via Lucky7366
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) This was my initial idea but they became heated when I suggested I was okay with them performing the maintenance across my entrance but did not wish to be a participant of the group share
1313GreenGreen1313 You start out by stating that the neighbor has been voluntarily organizing these services for years. I can only assume you agreed with this arrangement. Clearly, you have been paying your portion. What you have is a verbal agreement and a history of acceptance of the arrangement. Two things: 1. You can end the arrangement if you want. It's sort of of you to not have communicated your intent in advance. Slight a hole status there.
2. It sounds like the neighbor made decisions (prepay for next season's lawn and new snow removal costs) without you. The way you mention the prepay situation implies that this is the first time the prepay situation has come up. Have you prepaid in the past? The increased snow removal costs have been communicated or you would not know about them. I don't think you have a reasonable criticism on changing snow removal costs. The only real issue is that money was prepaid for future costs instead of
via 1313GreenGreen1313
Jaded_Elderberry_957 (OP) I have mentioned in the past that I do not wish to participate in the group share and they stated that if I did not, everyone else's prices would go up. I told them I would prefer to do the work myself, but in effort to not have their prices go up, I would contribute out of good will. Now that these prices are excessive and they are assigning previously collected funds to things I did not agree to and asking for additional payments, I told them I no longer wish to parti
Then, contact the vendors yourself directly and verify everything. You could guise it as wanting to shop around quotes, but be firm that you need this information. If they refuse to show proof of how the money is spent, I'd dig deeper or demand my money back on the spot.
via ixnayhombre
Mitch_Hunt Why has no one bought a machine capable of doing these things? Those prices are insane.
buttfacenosehead Does this person have proof of how the funds were redirected? Do they just expect everyone to take them at their word? That's ridiculous. Even if they did have receipts for future lawn-care, was there an agreement authorizing the collector to redirect snow removal funds elsewhere?
LengthinessGloomy429 Wait until the summer comes but the lawn care doesn't.
Polite_Bark Either your neighbor is a fool overpaying for services or they're lying and keeping the money. There is no reason to continue this arrangement. Handle your own snow removal or hire someone to do it for you. I'd bet a container of my favorite ice cream it would be far, far, less expensive.
SaltPaint8964 That's a lot of money considering multiple households contribute. You're right - you need to be part of any discussion involving money.
Iowa Native1 For $9,000 I would take that contract myself and be able to pay for the equipment first year
FloridaManTPA Guy is stealing, get the records
gumby_twain NTA If you want to feel better about it, they breached contract, verbal or otherwise, by using this years snow money to prepay for next year's lawn care That alone puts them in an actionable position. If I were you, I'd sue to recover the money you paid for services you are not receiving (this year's snow removal) and you never authorized using those funds for next year's lawn.
Then I'd never contribute to their grift again. The neighbor who is organizing it is definitely getting a kickback on those insane prices. If they don't like clearing your driveway to get to theirs, they can build their own driveway somewhere else. Oh yeah, I'd talk to a lawyer about that lack of easement YESTERDAY.
via gumby_twain
FinnYooper I live in a lake effect snow area where the average seasonal snowfall is 240". I plow my own driveway but my sister was only paying $1800 per season for her driveway to be cleaned. If I understand correctly this cost would be $1000 or half the spring collection plus $3000. $4000 is plain ridiculous. There isn't any way I'd agree to pay that amount.
at-the-crook The person that collected the money for the snow plowing really messed up. They represented that the funds would be used for one purpose and then re-allocated those funds for a different purpose. Plus - they did not ask permission to use the funds in a different manner.
Make your copy of the original fee request to prove that. I'm guessing they were not authorized to spend those funds for a different purpose. An attorney can provide an opinion on how you all should proceed.
via at-the-crook
shoulda-known-better Yea I'd want to see all those receipts before I paid a cent more.... Id also drop out of the whole arrangement fully including the lawn immediately
darkbyrd I'd be the a_h_le. He's dropped the ball to the tune of many thousands of dollars with no paper trail, and spent your money on what wasn't agreed on (future landscape maintenance)
via darkbyrd
wistah978 An extra 3 grand each for snow removal? Payable over 6 months? If you live anywhere that gets that kind of snow, you live in an area that has other companies who will plow. You and your neighbors need to get a couple quotes on you own then have a meeting and ask to see receipts from the current organizer.
via wistah978
If those numbers are accurate, you'll do better buying a machine that can clear the section needed to access your house and let the neighbors know their contractor is welcome to access the road but you'll handle your own section.
via wistah978
worstatit Sounds like neighbors landscaping buddy went out of the snow removal business and neighbor allowed them to keep the money anyway under guise of future lawn care.
via worstatit
RevengeOfTheldiot 2k a year is nuts lol. What lawn care is there on a driveway that adds to that much
Potent_Bologna I totally agree with you. He can't make you contribute to this and the more he pushes, the more suspicious he sounds. He could be lying and lining his pockets with your money. I'd want to contact the company he is using and ask for copies of the invoice for the lawn service that's prepaid. Directly from the company, not through him. Then I'd want to handle my own snow removal and wash my hands of the nonsense after the prepaid lawncare is completed. Even if he's not directly steal

This long response was very skeptical of the entire thing

Ok Illustrator3931 The neighbor is not entitled. There is no contract. He has just been in charge of doing this for years and trying to run this play but has no authority. There should be some written agreement. After he collected $2000 from each neighbor, did he provide paid invoices? Is there transparency of the funds he collect? The whole prepay for the following year is BS!!! Did he show proof of payments for the prepaid lawn care for the next year? In other words if he is not showing where
I would not group up with the neighbors anymore on this issue. You own the property so there's no contract. I would also go to the city or the county about the easements and get it recorded and modified for your entrance if you can. And also it wouldn't hurt to consult with a construction attorney or a real estate attorney on this matter concerning your easement situation.
via Ok_Illustrator3931
If he has not done so already, it is only fair that he be transparent with all the neighbors and show receipts, and proof of payments to where the money went. If he has a problem with doing so, then that is proof he has not be honest with the community. I mean what is anybody going to do? They can't do anything about it if you say no and no longer want to participate anymore. Besides you own the entrance, there's no contract, there's no HOA. It sounds like it was a good thing you all had going u
via Ok_Illustrator3931
No-Ear7988 The only shady/weird thing I'm hearing here is news 8 months later. Id navigate this carefully. Let all your partner neighbors know exactly why you will no longer participate in shared cost, get ahead of this neighbor so they can't change the narrative, and keep it short explanation. That being said sometimes its worth biting the bullet and forgive neighbor just to keep the peace.
Every-Caramel-6740 $500 a month, from every neighbor? That's $1000 more than the original cost for both. Nope, I'd also look into that easement
Practical-Demand-790 I don't understand the layout. The way you've described it, you can't use your own driveway either without clearing the entrance? So you could drop out of the common arrangement, but you'd still have to clear the driveway yourself or by hiring a contractor yourself, no? It just sounds like you guys need to be more involved in the contractor selection process instead of relying on the one neighbor to do everything for you.
3xlduck Per month? I would want to audit this.
via 3xlduck
No_Focus_4896 That's too expensive, they need to find a different snow plow operator
CW-Eight With no easement, you hold all the cards. It sounds like you want to be kind and reasonable about things, which is admirable. But when a neighbor is NOT being kind and reasonable starts pulling this s it, you should use those cards. I would tell them, in no uncertain terms, that if you want continued access, then this is how we will do things from now on. You have the control, use it.
via CW-Eight
Secret_Experience_47 Get more quotes for snow removal as the price seems high. $3k per household for snow removal when $2k used to be annual seems steep. Though maybe you were getting a crazy deal on a long- standing contract that no one is going to match. You should not let the contractor do your driveway and refuse to pay. Either do it yourself or pay the shared cost.
Sea-Professional3055 Sounds like some sheisty s t.. did anyone see receipts? would not be surprised if that persons probably been pocketing the excess
SomeGuyInThe315 $2k annually? What kind of maintenance is this?
SomeGuyInThe315 I pay less than that for an hoa and at least that covers the roof and sidewalk replacement. Your neighbor is stealing your money
ThetaGatherer That is a lot of money for snow removal. Get quotes from other snow removal companies, and each household pays their share directly to the snow removal company. Also drafting and proposing an easement with a lawyers help might be good if you have to allow others to cross your property. In that easement, you can specify exactly how maintenance is paid and split amongst users.
Gloomy-Respond3985 I'm stumped. Why would you buy property with restrictive encumbrances not legally memorialized?
OneLessDay517 Do YOU use the section of driveway that will be cleared? If yes, you should pay your share. However, your neighbor unilaterally deciding to use the money collected for something other than its intended purpose is theft. And if neighbor doesn't correct that situation, I'd be seeing them in court.
Mammoth_Negotiation7 It doesn't sound like you have a legal contract and even if you did, you paid for this year. There was no agreement to pre-pay next year's lawn maintenance. I'd tell him to pound sand. I'd at the very minimum ask for receipts and to view the contract for said lawn care. I'd also start looking into the legal side of neighbors accessing their homes via your property. You might be able to charge them access fees. Maybe you could use that as a bargaining chip.
Puzzleheaded_Bell104 The neighbor unilaterally decided to prepay lawn care for next year. Therefore he needs to unilaterally make up the difference for snow removal this year. Next year he can apply his advance payment to his share of lawn care. If you pay him extra this year and he moves away, you're out the money. Not the AH. Neither is the neighbor. He just should have thought this through a little better.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article